Medicare Plans in Indiana

How Do I Enroll in Medicare in Indiana?

To enroll in Original Medicare, do one of the following:

  • Submit an online application.
  • Apply in person at a Social Security office.
  • Call 800-772-1213 to speak with a Social Security employee.

What Indiana Medicare Plans Are Available? 

The plans available for those who live in Indiana are Medicare Part A, Part B, Medicare Advantage and Medicare Part D. You also have the option to enroll in a Medicare Supplement plan, which you would sign up for with a private insurance company. The government subsidizes the cost of Medicare, so your cost could be greatly reduced by your Social Security benefits. There are deductibles and copays that you will be responsible for, so understanding your plan and what is covered will help you plan better for your medical costs.  

The plans available and what they cover follow below:

  • Medicare Part A: This plan is part of the original Medicare law and covers the cost of emergency services and inpatient care. It also provides coverage for nursing care, home health care and hospice care. 

  • Medicare Part B: This is also part of the original Medicare package and covers the cost of your preventative care, such as doctor’s visits, diagnostic testing, medical supplies and medical equipment.  

  • Medicare Advantage: Congress passed a bill in 2006 that was signed into law allowing Medicare recipients the option of choosing a private insurance company to administer coverage in place of the federal government. These plans are Medicare Advantage plans, and while you are able to choose your insurer, a portion of your costs is subsidized via your Social Security benefits. Some Advantage plans let you receive coverage for things not offered by Medicare Part A and B, such as prescription medications, dental and vision coverage. 

  • Medicare Part D: This is your prescription drug plan under Medicare. Even if you are enrolled in Medicare Advantage, you may choose to enroll in Medicare Part D. This is advised if your Medicare Advantage plan does not cover the cost of your medications.  

  • Medigap Coverage: Medicare Supplement plans, also referred to as Medigap, cover the gap in your coverage and what you are required to pay. For example, Medicare Part B covers 80% of your medical costs after you meet your deductible, but a Medigap plan would help reduce what you would need to pay out of pocket by covering a portion of your copay.

Traditional Medicare plans are much more popular than Medicare Advantage in the state of Indiana. Around 1.3 million people enrolled in Medicare Part A and B, and 44% of those beneficiaries opted for a Medicare Advantage plan.

If you are having trouble deciding which plan is right for you, evaluate whether you have medical conditions or needs that would be covered by a Medicare Advantage plan or if you feel that Medicare Part A and B are sufficient. Medicare Supplement plans are an excellent way to reduce your co-payment and out-of-pocket expenses. 

Who Is Eligible for Indiana Medicare? 

Chances are that if you have already been receiving Social Security, you will be enrolled automatically if you have not been already. Most people meet the criteria for automatic enrollment, but if you have not been drawing your benefits long enough or did not contribute enough into Social Security while you were working, you will be required to enroll yourself. Auto-enrollment occurs on the day that you turn 65 unless you choose to opt into a different plan, such as Medicare Advantage. 

Medicare Part A will not cost you anything because it is part of your Social Security benefits as long as you met the required contributions over your life. Medicare Part B does cost around $150 for most people, but this is taken out of your Social Security or pension payments automatically so you don't need to send payment.  

Medicare Advantage lets you have more control over your coverage because of the ability to choose your insurer. Because your plan will be subsidized by the government, you could reduce the cost of your coverage significantly. Some people are able to get Medicare Advantage plans free of charge, but this is rare. The cost of your Medicare Part D plan will depend on the level of prescription drug coverage you want or need. 

Your initial enrollment period for Medicare begins three months prior to your birthday and runs for another three months after. It is really important to enroll during this time because you will be penalized and forced to pay higher premiums for the rest of your life if you don't. There are several special circumstances where you can avoid this penalty if you miss your initial enrollment period. 

General enrollment occurs from January 1 to March 31 every year and lets those who missed their Initial Enrollment Period enroll if they decide they would like to do so. If you missed your deadline because you were taking care of a family member with a disability, you served overseas or you were still covered under a work health care policy, you are able to avoid the penalty by waiting for a special enrollment period.  

If you're interested in enrolling in a Medicare Supplement plan, you do need to act quickly. You have six months beyond your birthday to enroll, and as long as you do it within this timeframe, your insurer is unable to deny you coverage or increase your rates based on your age, medical history or medical conditions. If you do not act within six months of your 65th birthday, you will lose these vital protections. 

How Do I Enroll in Indiana Medicare? 

The process for applying for Medicare is rather straightforward. Visit the Medicare website at Medicare.gov to see your status, enroll in a plan or change to a Medicare Advantage plan. All you need to do is follow the directions on the site, and you can complete the process from your computer.  

Average Cost of Medicare Advantage Plans in Indiana

Average Cost of Medicare Advantage Plans in Indiana
Average Monthly Premium $38.53
Average in-network out-of-pocket spending limit $6,122.75
Average drug deductible in 2024 (weighted) $368.79
Percentage of plans rated 4 stars or higher 62.8%
Average Cost of Medicare Advantage Plans in Indiana
Average Monthly Premium
$38.53
Average in-network out-of-pocket spending limit
$6,122.75
Average drug deductible in 2021 (weighted)
$368.79
Percentage of plans rated 4 stars or higher
62.8%

Indiana Medicare Advantage Plans by County

The chart below provides more information about Medicare Advantage plan costs and enrollment in Indiana by county in 2024.

Scroll to the right to continue reading the chart
County Average Premium Average Annual Drug Deductible % of Plans Rates 4 Stars or Higher # of Plans Available
Johnson $36 $393 55.6% 54
Boone $38 $393 53.6% 56
Shelby $36 $393 52.7% 55
Hamilton $37 $393 54.4% 57
Allen $34 $389 58.8% 51
Lake $35 $389 56.9% 58
Hancock $36 $393 52.7% 55
Hendricks $37 $393 54.4% 57
Marion $37 $402 55.2% 58
Morgan $36 $372 63.0% 46
Delaware $36 $372 63.0% 46
Madison $35 $372 61.2% 49
Porter $35 $380 58.2% 55
Harrison $43 $333 63.0% 46
Clark $41 $347 63.8% 47
Floyd $41 $347 63.8% 47
Randolph $53 $332 64.8% 54
Bartholomew $35 $358 63.6% 44
Warrick $37 $381 60.4% 48
Owen $37 $396 64.4% 45
Pike $53 $367 66.0% 50
White $36 $345 63.8% 47
Vigo $42 $362 69.2% 39
Franklin $50 $341 69.2% 52
Warren $51 $362 67.3% 52
Knox $53 $356 65.3% 49
Fayette $53 $340 68.6% 51
St Joseph $35 $368 66.0% 50
Elkhart $34 $377 63.8% 47
Jasper $34 $367 65.2% 46
La Porte $34 $368 64.6% 48
Howard $37 $362 61.2% 49
Dearborn $37 $344 64.4% 45
Vanderburgh $36 $393 61.2% 49
Carroll $35 $359 63.0% 46
Dubois $35 $381 63.6% 44
Martin $37 $381 62.2% 45
Starke $33 $379 65.2% 46
Fountain $51 $362 67.3% 52
Gibson $38 $367 59.6% 47
Vermillion $60 $350 72.7% 44
Lagrange $35 $363 61.4% 44
Wayne $52 $340 66.7% 51
Ripley $36 $384 65.9% 44
Pulaski $33 $379 65.2% 46
Washington $35 $350 62.8% 43
Switzerland $36 $347 64.4% 45
Marshall $32 $392 66.0% 47
Putnam $39 $358 60.4% 48
Rush $35 $383 65.1% 43
Jackson $37 $361 63.0% 46
Jefferson $37 $350 62.2% 45
Montgomery $36 $396 62.5% 48
Scott $37 $350 62.2% 45
Crawford $32 $385 65.9% 44
Clinton $38 $349 60.4% 48
Greene $37 $349 61.4% 44
Orange $32 $384 65.1% 43
Wabash $34 $377 63.6% 44
Cass $35 $355 59.6% 47
Sullivan $35 $383 62.8% 43
Spencer $36 $367 62.8% 43
Ohio $34 $347 63.6% 44
Jennings $35 $361 62.2% 45
Posey $38 $367 59.6% 47
Parke $36 $372 62.2% 45
Clay $37 $358 61.4% 44
Newton $52 $345 67.3% 52
Grant $33 $377 63.0% 46
Henry $52 $362 65.4% 52
Blackford $36 $353 61.4% 44
Decatur $37 $358 64.4% 45
Union $51 $354 69.2% 52
Monroe $34 $372 63.8% 47
Miami $33 $379 62.2% 45
Lawrence $36 $383 64.4% 45
Brown $37 $372 63.8% 47
Daviess $53 $367 64.6% 48
Steuben $32 $404 63.6% 44
Fulton $32 $392 66.0% 47
Perry $35 $342 63.6% 44
Jay $36 $365 61.4% 44
Benton $50 $370 67.9% 53
Tippecanoe $35 $372 63.8% 47
Tipton $35 $362 60.4% 48
Noble $34 $377 62.2% 45
Adams $32 $391 63.6% 44
Huntington $34 $377 63.0% 46
Kosciusko $34 $377 63.0% 46
Wells $34 $377 63.0% 46
Dekalb $34 $377 62.2% 45
Whitley $35 $363 62.2% 45

Contact Information for Indiana Medicare, Medicaid and Insurance Help

If you would like more information about Medicare and other assistance with your medical care, you can check out the following resources. 

State Health Insurance Assistance Program 

Indiana Medicaid Eligibility and Enrollment 

Indiana DOI 

Hoosier Healthwise 

Hoosier RX